Toby’s Original Little Italy Pizza

Disston Heights · St. Petersburg

Also listed in: Family Friendly St. Pete Over 50 St. Pete

Toby’s Original Little Italy Pizza photo source

New York pizza, subs and garlic knots at a family-run shop that dates to 1972. Toby’s is on 49th Street North in Disston Heights, well away from the downtown pizza strip. Its ordering page asks customers to allow about 20 minutes for pickup during the week and longer on Friday and Saturday. The restaurant’s October 30 post invites customers to its 54th anniversary celebration on November 29. Call ahead for a whole pie when the dinner rush is building.

Address
3523 49th Street N, St. Petersburg, FL
Phone
(727) 522-2717
Website
tobysoriginallittleitalypizza.com
Cuisine
pizza, italian
Verification
Details researched November 15, 2026. Hours and offerings change, so confirm with the venue before visiting.
46th Street North38th Avenue North49th Street North
The bright pin is Toby’s Original Little Italy Pizza. The other pins are nearby spots we cover; tap one to open it. Drawn from OpenStreetMap data, © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Community submissions

No community submissions for Toby’s Original Little Italy Pizza yet.

Submit a Spot

Discovery profile 16 of 17 readable

For whoever runs Toby’s Original Little Italy Pizza. This is what a search engine or an AI assistant can currently read about the place. It is free, it is here whether the venue joins in or not, and it can be corrected any time.

Nothing ties this venue to a discovery category yet. That is the finding, not an oversight ... we have no verified signal to file it under one.

  • Street address on file: yes
  • Neighborhood assigned: yes
  • Phone number published: yes
  • Website on file: yes
  • Hours published: yes
  • Cuisine or specialty described: yes
  • Photography on file: yes
  • Website reachable: pass HTTP 200
  • Served over HTTPS: pass
  • Structured data present: pass Declared: WebPage, ReadAction, ImageObject, BreadcrumbList, ListItem, WebSite
  • Declares a business type: fail A Restaurant, BarOrPub, or LocalBusiness type is what puts a venue into local answer sets.
  • Page description written: pass
  • Menu linked from the homepage: pass
  • Hours published on site: pass
  • Address published on site: pass
  • Social profiles linked: pass instagram.com, facebook.com
  • Open to AI crawlers: pass No AI crawler is blocked in robots.txt.

Website checks last run November 22, 2026 against the venue's own site.

Run this place? If we have you filed wrong, or we are missing what you most want to be known for, tell us. Corrections are free.

Claim this profile How this works

Real People
Local Love
All Welcome
Extend Your Visibility

Find your next favorite spot

Get BellyUp! finds for your city and the things you love.

What do you love?